Excellent condition. Prior appraisal information from Bonhams and Butterfield in SF. 1. Zhu Chang (17th Century): Landscape, 76 x 34 inches, $6,000-8,000
76x34
Hello, this item is a large vertical hanging scroll painting attributed to Zhu Chang (朱常), a Ming dynasty prince and 17th-century literati painter. The scroll measures approximately 76 x 34 inches and has been professionally mounted in a wooden frame behind glass. The landscape subject—with a scholar’s retreat among mountains—and the accompanying calligraphy with a red seal are consistent with literati style works of the late Ming period, particularly those influenced by Dong Qichang’s “Southern School” aesthetics. The composition, including both imagery and inscription, suggests classical Chinese ideals of cultivated solitude and poetic reflection.
Given the prior appraisal by Bonhams & Butterfield citing a valuation range of $6,000 to $8,000 USD, and provided that the scroll remains in excellent condition, this estimate remains current. The attribution to Zhu Chang—while plausible stylistically—requires authentication through seal verification, brushwork analysis, and paper dating to confirm its 17th-century origin, as Zhu’s works are relatively rare and often subject to reproduction in later centuries.
Hi Bonnie, I understand your frustration, but it’s important to clarify that value doesn’t automatically increase over tim, especially when attribution remains unverified. The estimate reflects the current market reality for works of this kind, not a fixed trajectory based on past appraisals.
This appraisal is dissipating in that it reflects the exact same value that I provided to you by a prior appraiser from many years ago and does not reflect an increase in value over time as it should have.