1851 Model Navy Revolver by Metropolitan Arms co of New York
15 February 2023
Description

6 shot revolver which I believe is a 1851 Colt Navy model. Manufacturer is Metropolitan Arms co New York serial number 6280. Etching is not very visible on cylinder. Unsure if any components are replacements. There seems to be some issue with the trigger/hammer mechanisms which inconsistently allows the trigger to engage the hammer and lock into a firing position. Has not been fired in at least 60 years. There are noticeable gouges on the cylinder and a missing screw, otherwise I would assume it has normal wear and tear from age. Is in a left handed holster, unsure if that is original to gun.

Dimensions

Approximately 13in long x 5in high x 1.75in wide.

Provenance

Inherited after fathers death, in my possession since 2011. Was in my fathers possession since the 1960's. Unsure of any history on the item as my father knew nothing about it. I believe it was given to him by his father.

Acquired from
Inherited
For sale
Maybe
Answered within 1 day
By Gregory
Feb 17, 08:39 UTC
Fair Market Value
$1,000 - $2,000 USD
Suggested Asking Price $1,500 USD
What does this mean?

Dear Charles,

Thank you for contacting Mearto with your appraisal inquiry.

The presented object appears to be a Metropolitan Model 1851 Navy revolver. It has a .36 caliber with no engraving on the cylinder, octagonal barrel and the serial number 6280. The Colt factory burnt to the ground in 1864 and the Metropolitan Co. of New York City seized the opportunity to made a nearly exact replica of the Colt 1851 Navy between 1864 to 1866.
Comparable objects were recently offered and sold on the international auction market.
This piece is in good condition and no severe damage is visible in the images provided.
A fair market estimation would be between 1.000 to 2.000 USD.
This estimate is based on actual recent past recorded auction sales of comparable items. Retail "asking prices" can be higher and may vary.

With kind regards,
Gregory

Do you have a similar item and want to know how much it’s worth?

Communicate directly with a qualified specialist and get a fair market valuation of your item, typically in 48 hours or less.

Similar item appraisals

24 Jun, 2026
1842 pistol
Antique Guns
Estimate: No appraisals
21 Jun, 2026
Very Rare Wilson ...
Antique Guns
Estimate: $450 - $900
16 Jun, 2026
Ww2 30 cal, offic...
Antique Guns
Estimate: No appraisals
16 Jun, 2026
Powder horn from ...
Antique Guns
Estimate: No appraisals
14 Jun, 2026
1866 French Rifle
Antique Guns
Estimate: No appraisals
1 Jun, 2026
Indian pattern br...
Antique Guns
Estimate: No appraisals
29 May, 2026
Winchester 45-60
Antique Guns
Estimate: $2,500 - $4,500
23 May, 2026
P38 German Luger ...
Antique Guns
Estimate: $3,500 - $6,500
17 May, 2026
French Berthier?
Antique Guns
Estimate: No appraisals